Friday, August 17, 2007

The Foolishness of God

Does Christianity make sense? Do all its various teachings add up? Is it logical?

For a time, I began to think - yes. It must make sense.

Something within me demanded logical explanations to all the haunting questions of the ages. “Why am I saved and not others?” “Why do the innocent suffer?” “What is the point of my life?” “What is the REAL truth and how am I to know it?” etc. etc.

I started to think that if Christianity can’t answer these big questions in a logically airtight, satisfying way, what good is it?

But this kind of thinking and search for logical answers (thankfully) proved fruitless.

Oh, I know there are Christian pat answers to these big questions. The best theological minds down through history (and continuing mercilessly in our time) offer us lots of ways to explain God and try to harmonize human logic with what we find in the Bible. But most of this is just interesting speculation. What I found was - regardless of which logical path I followed - God eventually ended up being either non-existent, impotent or a monster. So much for my logic.

Now I am certain that Christianity does NOT make sense. Christian theology is the very opposite of philosophy. It springs from different premises, operates by different rules, and in most cases (perhaps all?) cannot be reconciled with natural reason.

And that’s OK. In fact, it’s more than OK. If God is to stay God, it is the way it must be. When God and my reason collide, my reason necessarily yields, whether I like it or not. And I admit I seldom like it.

I am currently re-reading a book that has been in my library for many years - The Foolishness of God, The Place of Reason in the Theology of Martin Luther by Siegbert Becker. It is a fascinating and comforting book, because Prof. Becker (correctly, I think) uncovers the key to understanding Luther’s seeming anti-rationalism. He explains and defends Luther’s way of fitting Scripture, faith and reason together by relegating reason to its proper place - as a servant of Scripture and faith, not their master or judge. Put in a somewhat more spiritual way, faith inevitably puts natural reason to death, giving birth to a sanctified use of human reason, ruled by faith. (We don’t check our brain at the door. It is exchanged for a new one.)

The irony of the book is that it obviously employs human reason (as any book written by humans must) in a way that makes Luther’s unreasonableness totally reasonable. Or, as one commentator put it, “Luther may have been antirationalistic, but he was not irrational.”(David Scaer)

While all this sometimes makes my head swim, (using human reason to analyze human reason is a somewhat circular process), I believe that a simple recognition of the limits of natural reason is a gracious ingredient of the gift of faith. And it is immensely freeing.

Prof Becker’s book is not just a key to understanding Luther. It provides, I believe, a key to understanding Christianity itself. An escape, if you will, from the bondage of the fallen mind.

8 comments:

Nathan said...

T. Hahm,

I've been following your blog for a while now. You are clearly an "out-of-the-box" thinker.

Me too. I'm wondering if you might be up for reading something I've written that deals with many of the same difficult questions you like to deal with.

Its a little bit long, but managable. Let me know if you're interested and we'll talk about email addresses (I can't find yours and I'm not crazy about sharing mine either!).

T. Hahm said...

Nathan,

I'd love to read it. Feel free to eMail me at hahmt2000@yahoo.com.

Phil said...

Hey, T,

I'm just posting to see if I can. Everything you said, yeah. Rock on.

L P Cruz said...

Dear Mr Hahm,

Might you have considered Dr. Greg Jackson's critique that counters universalism?

For what it is worth

http://ichabodthegloryhasdeparted.blogspot.com/search/label/UOJ

God's peace,


L P Cruz

Fraiser said...

It appears you stopped blogging. Come back! Your posts are great and your readers miss them. Please resume blogging.

Bob Rhyne said...

Terry, you are such a terrific embodiment of faith and intellect. I love your stuff!

Anonymous said...

i actually enjoy your writing way, very interesting.
don't quit and keep posting due to the fact that it just simply worth to follow it.
looking forward to browse a whole lot more of your own writing, have a good day!

Byron said...

Lon time no blog. It's time to srart up again.